Quicken 2015 for Windows Review – Analyze Your Investment Portfolio

I’ve been a long-time user of Intuit’s Quicken since 1992 — now over 20 years. My family and I track 60+ accounts within Quicken. So to say I’m a power-user of their product would be an understatement. We have every bank account, credit card, asset, retirement, investment, and liability linked within the software. For this review of Quicken Premier 2015 for Windows, I bought a copy from Amazon and converted from my previous version of Quicken 2014.

The conversion from Quicken 2014 to 2015 took about ten minutes to complete, and was more descriptive than previous. This conversion process was flawless, and I did not have any issues.

Intuit never does radical changes with their annual software updates, as they incrementally add features to Quicken, and the enhancements tend to be evolutionary rather than revolutionary.

In today’s cloud/web 2.0/Internet world, Quicken is no longer the only game in town. It’s possible to completely store your financial information online using services like Intuit’s own Mint.com service, or what we recommend Personal Capital.

However, these financial aggregation services tend to be read-only, and are more for alerting or reporting your finances. And reconciliation and online bill pay isn’t usually available with these types of services.

For individuals who prefer to stay with a locally installed application, there is also YNAB (You Need A Budget), Moneydance, or if you are looking for a native Macintosh software application there is iBank as well.

Though none of the mentioned applications come close to Quicken in marketshare usage, or from our tests, the comprehensive personal finance features make Quicken for Windows the leader in the industry, and there’s no question why this is the case (though the others are catching up).

Quicken 2015 vs. Quicken 2014

Quicken 2015 for Windows adds even less new features than previous years. The major new features are:

  • Portfolio X-Ray – Available with Premier and higher, you can get insights from Morningstar into your investment portfolio
  • Free Credit Score – This is something Intuit also added to their Mint.com service as well
  • Mobile Improvements – Syncing occurs faster and spending graphs
  • Improved Options Trades – Ability to better handle options trades in the register

It’s nice to see after many years of little or no improvements, they’ve finally added a new functionality to the investment section.

Portfolio X-Ray

Quicken's  Morningstar X-ray service
Breakdown your investment asset allocation with Morningstar (click to enlarge)
Now with Quicken 2015 Premier and higher, this feature is built right in. It slices and dices your portfolio and tells you where you are under allocated, and where you are over allocated.

New for 2015 is the Quicken Portfolio X-Ray feature. In partnership with Morningstar this is a much welcomed feature, and wish Morningstar had this available on their website.

While I love using Morningstar for research and thinking their X-Ray tool is invaluable, it was too cumbersome to manually enter the investments. I also was never able to get the export out of Quicken to work correctly with Morningstar’s X-Ray tool. So I didn’t use the X-Ray tool as much as I would have liked to.

For those not familiar with Morningstar’s X-Ray tool it dissects your portfolio into these areas:

  • Asset Allocation – What percentage of stocks, bonds and other asset classes
  • World Regions – How much you have invested around the world
  • Stock Sectors – How much is invested in various industries
  • Stock and Bond Style – With stocks: how much is invested in Value, Core and Growth, vs. Small, Mid and Large Cap stocks.
  • Fees & Expenses – Breakdown of your overall annual expense ratio

In my situation it recommends I decrease my allocation to Asia, and I have too much exposure to financial services. Unfortunately the one limitation (which is the same with Morningstar’s service) is the ability to adjust your asset allocation, and adjust your risk profile for “what if” scenarios.

Free Credit Score

Quicken Free Credit Score
Get a financial checkup of your credit score (click to enlarge)
Another neat feature in Quicken 2015 is the ability to generate a free credit score. Though in my case wasn’t able to get this working within Quicken because of some Cloud ID issue.

This was also recently added into Mint.com as well. Though it’s not without its limitations. Intuit pulls your credit score from only one of the three credit agencies (Equifax), so it’s not as useful when compared to Credit Karma.

Intuit’s service also doesn’t monitor your credit score or negative changes so the report is only useful for that moment in time. Unfortunately, if you are married, there doesn’t appear to be a way to get a credit score for your spouse.

Features Added in Previous Versions of Quicken

Thinking about upgrading from an existing version of Quicken, but not sure what’s changed since bought last? Here’s a summary of what features were added in previous versions.

New Features in Quicken 2014

  • Store and Save Receipts – You can take pictures of your receipts and store them within Quicken for later retrieval.
  • Memorized Transactions Show Up in Register – This is perhaps the best new feature I like. Previously you had to enter memorized transactions, but this feature will display future events within in the register before entering the transaction.
  • Overall Speed Improvements – While I did not do exact performance tests, it seems Quicken 2014 was much more responsive.
  • Mobile Synchronization Improvements – Many users complained how Quicken’s mobile synchronization was broken in 2013. Intuit claims, and from my testing so far, this feature has been improved.
  • Budget Improvements – Users also complained about 2013 and the budget changes. Quicken added two options that should satisfy users who want their budget displayed with including and excluding specific transactions.
  • More Connectivity Resolutions – Quicken 2014 makes it even easier to fix connectivity issues with your financial institution

New Features Quicken 2013

  • Quicken Mobile – First version of Quicken Mobile app for Apple and Android devices
  • Synchronization Improvements – Gave a step-by-step process to help with bank synchronization problems
  • New Budgeting Functionality – Though many users complained about this new functionality and was later improved in 2014

Technical Requirements

Quicken’s requirements have always been the middle to low lend-end of new computers sold. The specs listed below shouldn’t be an issue if your hardware is less than 3 years old. These are similar specs needed to run Quicken 2011, 2012, and 2013. I would recommend a slightly more powerful machine than listed. Note that Quicken 2015 does not support Windows XP which has been EOLed.

  • CPU: 1 GHz
  • Operating System: Windows Vista SP1, Windows 7/8/8.1 (32 and 64-bit)
  • Memory: 1 GB or more (I recommend at least 2GB; 4GB being ideal)
  • Hard Disk Space: Up to 450 MB free space; up to 1.5 GB if .NET not installed
  • Display: 1024×768 or higher resolution, 1280×1024 for large fonts
  • CD/DVD Drive: Recommended
  • Internet: 56 Kbps (broadband recommended for online services)
  • Sound: Sound Card and Speakers Recommended
  • Printer: Any printer supported by Windows Vista/7/8/8.1
  • Additional Software (included in Quicken installer): Microsoft .NET 4.0 or later

Using Quicken for Windows on a Macintosh

I’ve been using Quicken since my first MS-DOS computer in 1991. Now that I am a Macintosh user, I still prefer Quicken for Windows. Though the question becomes how do I run Quicken for Windows on my Macintosh?

Even with the recent release of Quicken 2015 for Mac, the product isn’t complete enough for my needs. It currently lacks bill paying, and lacks many of the features in the investing section.

So I run Quicken 2015 Premier for Windows by running it in a VMware Fusion 7 instance. If you want to find out more about this process you can read my article: How to Run Quicken for Windows on a Mac.

The added benefit of virtualizing Windows is an additional layer of security, since no other software is installed on that instance. You don’t have to worry about any rogue viruses or software compromising your finances. This technique is also possible on a Windows-based machine.

Quicken Review and Summary

The free credit score is a neat new feature, though you can get free credit scores from other services. The credit scoring also lacks monitoring, and can’t get a free report for your spouse.

The Portfolio X-Ray feature is the best new feature available in Quicken 2015 for Windows. Unlike Morningstar’s website it makes it easy to analyze your portfolio. As an investor, I welcome this addition.

Like the last few years, if you have a current version of Quicken, I don’t see any “must-have” features to upgrade. If you have no issues with your existing version, then there’s no real reason to upgrade.

If you have an EOL (End Of Life) version of Quicken, or currently don’t use Quicken, then it makes sense to purchase this version. I much prefer Quicken over Inuit’s Mint, because it can handle much more complex financial scenarios and it isn’t read only. Quicken can definitely grow with you as your finances become more complex — Mint on the other hand cannot.

Personal Capital is another possible option if you are looking for a purely cloud-based solution, and you want more complex investment reporting than Mint.com.

Quicken 2015 for Windows still remains the personal finance app to beat — locally installed or in the cloud.

Rating: 3 1/2 out of 5 stars

Save 40% on Quicken

Save 40% off your order. You can order and download immediately from Intuit’s website. I recommend Quicken Premier 2015 for its investment features. If unsure if Quicken is right for you, Intuit offers a 60-day money-back guarantee.

Hurry because this promotion is only for five days (till June 1st 2015).

Make a Comment

Your Email address will not be published.

*

Notify me of followup comments via Email. You can also subscribe without commenting.

Reader Comments

  1. says

    I have used Quicken for about 15 years now, and yes it’s changes are usually evolutionary. I can admit that I used Pocket Quicken on a Newton! Then a Palm Pilot!

    Most folks should use it, whether they want to or not!

  2. Alex Badgley says

    I am really cautious when buying programs that I am unsure of. Is the “The 60 day money back guarantee” allowed even when the program is installed? Thanks for the assistance.

  3. Carl Tippins says

    Have they fixed the mortgage loan update issue? I’m using Quicken 2014 and was excited to see the link to your mortgage loan accounts ….. unfortunately, it doesn’t work. I have several investment properties and really don’t want to enter the transaction details manually.

      • Carl Tippins says

        Mortgage loans don’t update at all…..balances, payments, transactions (such as amounts posted to principle and interest for each payment). I looked it up on the Quicken site once I realized it wasn’t working and it’s a known issue. :(

        • Rich Grega says

          Carl: you need to set the loans up as a manual loan – there is a tag at the bottom when you set up a loan to set it up as a manual loan. I was having the same issues with my mortgage and auto loans – the loan amounts weren’t reducing correctly.

          Go to the Quicken Community and type in “manual loan” to see various discussions on this issue.

          HTH

      • Carl Tippins says

        Forgot to tell you….the “work arounds”:
        #1 – Delete the accounts and create new online enabled accounts. (Did that, issue still occurred.)
        #2 – Delete the accounts and create new accounts that are not online enabled. This means you have to manually update the accounts every month. (Kind of defeats the whole purpose of using software that is suppose to update your accounts automatically.)

        If there was a different software out there that did all the things Quicken does (or, should I say, suppose to do) I would gladly switch. But, as you said in your article, nothing else exists that does everything Quick does.
        I have been using Quicken products for about 15 years. Quicken has the worst customer service around …. it’s practically non-existent. Instead of giving you an actual employee to interact with, they send you to “Quicken Community”. Where, evidently, the users must fix Quicken product issues. The installation of Quicken 2014 was the very first time I didn’t have an install issue upgrading the software. Every other upgrade had major issues resulting in completely having to de-install the old software, installing the new software, and re-creating every account from scratch. I can’t tell you how many time’s I cursed Intuit for providing such a lousy product. I would wait until I was threatened with “your downloads will stop working if you don’t update” before I would switch products. Reading the “community” site will make anyone question if they should buy Quicken. It’s sad, but what can you do when they provide all the bells and whistles no one else does.

        • Edward Boone says

          It is really amazing that in today’s market, an application can actually stagnate or regress. The application has numerous fundamental flaws such as checkboxes missing on reports when selecting accounts. As far as support, it is a joke and an insult that the user community, i.e. those that have paid for the product, are responsible for providing whatever support is available. Intuit should be ashamed of itself.

          • says

            I have contacted Quicken support a few times over the years, and not even once have they been able or willing to help.

            Another issue is the adds and popups they push to you, trying to get you to upgrade. You can not stop them without uninstalling the program.

        • Ric says

          I totally agree. I’ve been a Quicken user for about 25 years and I feel like I’m being held hostage. Quicken 2015 is the WORST update yet. And you are correct, they don’t understand customer service. They are sooooo fortunate to not have any competition. When they do, I’m gone!!!!!

  4. Dave Johnson says

    I loaded Q14 last year and have had difficulty with it since. I also purchased a new high res PC – Q14 doesn’t seem to be able to handle the high res without having to change the font and font size. It also doesn’t seem to move to the next downloaded transaction after the first is entered. Has Q15 addressed either of these issues?

  5. ThePricesAz says

    We have been Quicken users for 15 + years, and Q14 is THE GLITCHIEST version of the program that we’ve ever experienced. We are being heavily incentivized to upgrade to Q15 (50% off).

    We were hoping to find out from a review if the upgrade will solve the problems, but we don’t want to spend any more money on the program if the crashes and glitches aren’t worked out.

    • Rich Young says

      Same here – I’m so disgusted with the user interface and difficulty navigating in Quicken 2014 that I am not giving them another dime until I’m absolutely forced to, or when someone can convince me that a newer version works the way “normal” software does. Quicken 2014 seems like it was written by high school students who had never used a commercial software product before.

  6. Jim says

    I have also used Quicken for the last 15 years and do not plan on changing. But as someone who develops software for a living, I find this product atrocious in quality and user convenience, particularly for something with such a large market share and 20 year product history. I find it to be a very clunky product to use and simply do not understand the basic reason for it. The biggest internal complexity of this product is the downloading and synchronization with the varying financial institutions. The rest of the product is basic user interface candy and should be spectacular at this point in time. But… what else are you going to use? And I have always found their budgeting tool to be sloppy at best. And why are so many of their capabilities hidden down in weird menu selections. (Find me a quick button that says, “Budget”.) In all reality, this product is best of bad financial products and I would love to find something better.

  7. Pops says

    I also have been a Quicken user since the beginning (version 1.1 I think) I am disappointed that Intuit had cut the XP platform. XP-SP3 is a stable environment, sure EOLed but it will keep working for some time yet. It sucks that this app is trying to force an upgrade. I do not see any enhancements that justify the forced OS change. I’ll be sending my 2015 back. I might get the 2014 to upgrade my 2013. I usually upgrade every 2 years. New PC and OS are on my list but it will be on my time line not Intuit’s.

  8. says

    Based on the horrors of my Quicken 2014 upgrade (I’m also using Windows (7) on a virtual machine on my Mac), I’m very wary of believing this one won’t just be more bloatware that crawls for 5 minutes when I try to, say, update the amount of a transfer between accounts.

  9. RT says

    I’ve been a Quicken user since 1992 and each year the update has less and less new features. Additionally, every update I’ve used in my memorable past has been somewhat of a nightmare at first. I’ve found myself excited about the mobile version but when I tried it in 2013 and again this year it screwed up my data. From what I can gather, I think there are still major issues with the mobile product’s ability to use split transactions and transfers. That seems to be where all the problems lie. Additionally, the app just appears to be a glorified version of the mint.com app which would explain the limitations in these two areas.

    One change that I hated this year (albeit has little to do with the actual management of finances) is the change to the documents storage. I used this feature a lot and always hoped for some improvement. I found Quicken to be a great place to store documents such as receipts, invoices, statements, trade confirmations, correspondence with banks.. you name it. You used to be able to categorize these documents by type and view them within the application. Noe pdf’s are no longer viewable within Quicken and they are also no longer labeled/categorized so if you have multiple documents attached to one transaction or one date you have to guess at which one you’re looking for (especially if you typically attach pdf’s).

    As with all the quicken upgrades there are pains and it seems the new version was kicked out to meet a deadline before it was completed or tested. It seems as though all versions are built on revisions to which there are usually several within a short time period from it’s original release date. I upgraded a year earlier than I was required to given Quicken’s 3-year upgrade/support requirement and I think from now on I’ll take each version the actual 3 years or whatever the requirement may be.

    I really wish they could get a mobile app that is designed for Quicken to work well with quicken. Sadly, the old Palm OS app worked better the iOS or android apps they have now. It is rather clear that Quicken is the redhead step child of Intuit’s product lineup and it gets the least attention of any of their products.

  10. Jon says

    It is hard to see how this reviewer could have done any significant work with Quicken 2015 over time and not encountered major problems in core features. I am running the current release of Quicken Premiere 2015 (R 3) on a Windows 7-64 bit Professional system and still have repeated problems.

    If you have multiple accounts from different financial institutions and of different types, expect the conversion will cost you time in working around flaws in the software that somehow did not get noticed in this review. I have encountered bugs involving brokerage, bank, and credit card accounts. These have occurred with at least four different financial institutions.

    In the most major bug, I set up my Everbank accounts for automated transaction download (previously only one of them was on the manual web-connect download). The system renamed one of my Everbank accounts and deleted another. Unfortunately I found out about the deletion after making a bunch of manual entries to update another account. Make sure you backup your file before changing your online downloads!

    A second pattern is that Quicken’s online download will miss transactions for no reason. There is a workaround for this–you can reset the “starting date” for the account if this persists; however if you don’t notice this problem in time you may have to manually track down and update the transactions. Also having to hunt down and execute a workaround is a unacceptable. This has happened involving both a brokerage account and a bank with savings and checking accounts.

    With yet a fourth institution, it stopped downloading my credit card transactions and instead had an error message. Trying to “reset” the online setup using Quicken’s instructions provided by the error handling popups caused Quicken to freeze until I killed it with task manager. I tried the “reset” multiple times; each time Quicken froze and had to be killed. Finally, I was able to restore the automated download by deactivating and reactivating the online download for the account. This will cause both already cleared and reconciled as well as new positions to be downloaded; get ready for more manual cleanup work.

    • says

      Jon,

      I actively do use Quicken on a weekly and sometimes daily basis. The issues you describe are institution specific. It is impossible for Investor Junkie to test all financial accounts and setups of Quicken. Some of the issues you describe are not within Quicken itself but the online service that downloads the transactions. These are similar problems users report of Intuit’s other product Mint.com as well.

  11. Ally Larsen says

    Budgeting is something I’ve been thinking of doing and wanting to do for some time, but never got it done. Now that I’m newly separated, I need it more than ever. As someone who doesn’t have multiple mortgages/businesses, etc., is this still a great program? It looks good, but since its $50 I want to be sure it would be useful for just an average everyday usage.

  12. Len says

    I’ve been a Quicken User for over 20 years and I am extraordinarily disappointed at the continued non-stop decline in the quality of their software. Release 13 was buggy, R14 crashed too much, and R15 is even worse. Oh if only the market would give us a decent alternative, I would switch in a minute, or perhaps Intuit would get back to basics and release software that actually worked. How about a release with no features, just fix the crashes.

  13. Kanev75 says

    Advise the optimal (most stable) version of Quicken (2011, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015) without the use of INTUIT ID.
    I currently use a 2011 version.
    Updated to version 2015 do not want to because INTUIT ID.
    I do not want to be dependent on the Internet and often use different quicken files on different computers.
    I do not use Quicken Mobile
    I do not use bank synchronization.
    I enter all the data manually or imported from Excel.

    I use a budget.
    I use multicurrency.

    As far as I know from using a Q2014 INTUIT ID can be waived.
    Using the budget (budget and actual comparison of costs) better Q2011 or Q2014?
    Thank you

  14. Kanev75 says

    Unfortunately for Q2015 use INTUIT ID requirement.
    This is not an option.
    https://qlc.intuit.com/questions/893832-quicken-faq-why-is-quicken-asking-me-for-a-username-and-password-what-is-an-intuit-id-and-am-i-required-to-create-one

    I’ll be glad if you tell how to use the Q2015 without INTUIT ID and without the Internet.

  15. Marty J says

    After reading all these reviews, reported gliches and asociated problems, I have determined that the best course of action for me is to stick with Quicken 12 DeLuxe. Works great on Win 7-Pro 64 bit machine.
    Thanks for helping me decide NOT to upgrade

  16. John says

    The Quicken product has become so bad, that I’ve decided NOT to update the product again. This decision has been a difficult one as I’ve been using the product since 1999. Without any competition, Intuit will not address all the complaints, lack of customer service, and poor product performance until their sales drop significantly. I hope you’ll join me in sending this message.

  17. Michael Jasper says

    As with most other commenters, my experience with Quicken worsened with each upgrade starting around 2007. I finally gave up a few years ago and no longer use Quicken. I miss having a single desktop program that integrates everything, but the bugs had really taken over everything, and especially investment transaction import.
    Seeing a glowing review here does concern me, and makes me question all the other reviews on this site. Even if a reviewer doesn’t run into the same issues as users, I would expect them to flag the fact that users report such egregious problems.

    • Todd Salyards says

      I have used Quicken since day one! the 2015 version is horrible. I can’t find a way to save size and position of windows, and I get a “can not open file” message many times when closing a session. What the heck happened?