Investor Junkie
MENUMENU
  • Start Investing
    • HOW TO GET STARTED INVESTING

      New here? Just starting as an Investor?

      If you're a new investor and visiting Investor Junkie for the first time, then this is what you need to get started.

    • GETTING STARTED STEPS

      • Get Rid of Consumer Debt
      • Start ​​​​​​​Investing Now
      • Open a Retirement Account
      • Create an Asset Allocation
      • Minimize Taxes
      • Reduce Fees & ​​​​​​​Fund Expenses
      • Start a ​​​​​​​Side Hustle
      • Protect ​​​​​​​Your ASSets
      • Next Steps
  • Reviews
      • Recommended Services

      • Personal Capital
      • Betterment
      • YNAB
      • Acorns
      • Fidelity Investments
      • Ally Invest
    • Robo Advisors

      • Betterment
      • Wealthfront
      • Wealthsimple
      • Blooom
      • More Reviews

      Stock brokers

      • Ally Invest
      • E*TRADE
      • Merrill Edge
      • TD Ameritrade
      • More Reviews
    • Microsavings

      • Acorns
      • Digit
      • Stash Invest
      • Qapital
      • More Reviews

      Banking

      • Ally Bank
      • CIT Bank
      • Chime
      • EverBank
      • More Reviews
    • Personal Finance

      • Mint
      • Quicken
      • Personal Capital
      • YNAB
      • More Reviews

      Accounting

      • FreshBooks
      • QuickBooks
      • Sage Business Cloud Accounting
      • Wave
      • More Reviews
    • Real Estate

      • Fundrise
      • Realty Mogul
      • RealtyShares
      • PeerStreet
      • More Reviews

      Peer-to-Peer Lending

      • Lending Club
      • Prosper
      • Wunder Capital
      • YieldStreet
      • More Reviews
    • Investment Research

      • Barron’s
      • Morningstar
      • Stansberry Research
      • YCharts
      • More Reviews

      Financial Books

      • Rich Dad, Poor Dad
      • Money Master The Game
      • The Millionaire Next Door
      • The Best Finance Books
      • More Reviews
  • Compare
    • Robo Advisors

      • Betterment vs. Wealthfront
      • Betterment vs. Vanguard
      • Wealthfront vs. Vanguard
      • Wealthfront vs. Wealthsimple
      • Compare Others
    • Personal Finance

      • Quicken vs. Mint
      • Mint vs. Personal Capital
      • Mint vs. YNAB
      • Quicken vs. Personal Capital
      • Compare Others
    • Stock Brokers

      • Schwab vs. Fidelity
      • E*TRADE vs. TD Ameritrade
      • E*TRADE vs. Robinhood
      • Fidelity vs. Vanguard
      • Compare Others
    • Real Estate

      • Fundrise vs. Realty Mogul
      • Realty Mogul vs. RealtyShares
      • Fundrise vs. Rich Uncles
      • LendingHome vs. PeerStreet
      • Compare Others
    • Banking

      • Best Online Savings Account
      • Best Online CD Rates
      • Best Jumbo CD Rates
    • Peer-to-Peer Lending

      • Lending Club vs. Prosper

      Microsavings

      • Acorns vs. Stash
  • Learn
      • All Articles
      • Investing SecretsInvesting Secrets
      • The Mint ManualThe Mint Manual
      • SEE ALL ARTICLES
    • Budgeting

      • How Much Do I Need to Save per Month
      • What is Zero-Based Budgeting?
      • 50/30/20 Budgeting Doesn’t Work
      • Why I’ve Switched to Personal Capital
      • See All

      Robo Advisors

      • Robo-Advisor Overview
      • True Costs of the Robo-Advisors
      • Robo-Advisors vs. Target Date Funds
      • Robo-Advisors vs. Microsavings
      • What is Tax-Loss Harvesting
      • See All
    • Investing

      • How to Choose an Online Broker
      • How to Transfer to a New Broker
      • Invest Your First $1,000
      • Who Offers a Virtual Trading Account?
      • See All

      Real Estate

      • Investing in Real Estate
      • 3 Steps to Get Started as a Real Estate Investor
      • You’re a Fool to Prepay Your Mortgage
      • How to Use Your 401(K) as a Down Payment
      • Tax Lien Investing
      • See All
    • Retirement

      • How to Rollover a 401(K)
      • How to Maximize Your 401(k)
      • Target Date Funds Comparison
      • Roth IRA vs. Traditional IRA
      • See All

      Taxes

      • 2017 Retirement Plan Contribution Limits
      • Tax-Efficient Investing
      • Tax-Loss Harvesting
      • How to Pay $0 Tax on a Six-Figure Income
      • The Best Tax Software for Investors
      • See All
  • Promotions
    • Featured promotion
      Betterment

      Betterment

      BEST OFFER
      Up to one year managed free initial deposit

      Learn More
    • Stock Brokers

      • Ally Invest
      • E*TRADE
      • Firstrade
      • Merrill Edge
      • TD Ameritrade

      Best IRA Promotions

      Free Stock Trading

    • Robo Advisors

      • Betterment
      • Blooom
      • Wealthfront
      • Wealthsimple
      • Ellevest
    • Personal Finance

      • Quicken
      • QuickBooks
      • YNAB
    • Microsavings

      • Rize
      • Stash Invest
      • Acorns
    • Other

      • Lending Club
      • Roofstock
      • RealtyShares
      • YCharts
      • Personal Capital
Home > Robo Advisors > Robo-Advisors vs. Financial Advisors

Robo Advisors vs. Financial Advisors – Which One Should You Use?

By: Kevin Mercadante Updated: February 7, 2018

Robo advisors, or fully automated online investment platforms, are springing up quickly, appealing mainly to new and younger investors. But does that mean they’re right for every investor, in all circumstances? Are there times when you might be better off with a traditional investment advisor, rather than a robo advisor? Yes!

Here’s how to tell when a robo advisor or traditional investment advisor is the better choice. Let’s take a look at both sides.

When You Should Use a Robo Advisor

Robo advisors can be a real advantage when at least some of the following apply to your investment situation:

You fully understand the impact that investment fees have on your investment performance. How much you pay in investment fees can have a material effect on your investment performance, especially over the long term. Traditional investment advisors typically charge anywhere from 1% to 3% of the value of your portfolio, while robo advisors charge less than 1%. In fact, you can get robo advisors with investment fees as low as 0.15% per year to manage your investments. All things being equal, this can improve your investment performance dramatically.

You don’t need much in the way of direct contact. Some people like personal contact in connection with their investments, while others have no need for it. If you’re perfectly content turning the job of managing your investments over to someone else — with whom you have little, if any, contact — robo advisors are a good choice. Just make sure you’re okay with not having a human advisor to talk to in the event that the stock market crashes. That’s often when people most want to speak with an advisor or broker directly. If you’re prepared to ride out the downturn and you don’t have a need to analyze it with a person who is intimately familiar with your investments, then the robo advisor route will work for you.

You don‘t meet the minimum requirements for a traditional advisor. One of the major limitations of traditional investment advisors is the account minimum balance requirement. Most require you to have at least $200,000 in your portfolio before they will even consider working with you. Others will look for even higher minimums, such as $500,000 or even $1 million. Robo advisors will provide professional investment management of a portfolio with as little as $5,000. Some will even allow you to open an account with no minimum balance. This is a big part of the reason why robo advisors are more popular among new or young investors.

You’re willing to let someone else do ALL your investing. When you invest in a robo investing platform, the site will handle all of your investment activities for you. All you need to do is fund your account. If you prefer this kind of investment arrangement, a robo advisor will work well for you.

When You Should Use a Traditional Investment Advisor

Despite the rising popularity of robo advisors, many people still prefer having a traditional investment advisor. This may be you if any of the following apply:

You’re not comfortable transacting business online. Some people, typically younger generations, are perfectly okay conducting all of their business on the web. But not everyone is this way. If this describes you, then you’re probably better off with a traditional investment advisor.

Direct human contact is very important to you. If you prefer having direct human interaction regarding your investments, you’re best to stay with traditional investment advisors. They will not only manage your portfolio for you, but they’ll also be available to discuss your questions and concerns. Robo advisors typically allow you some form of phone access, but there’s no one at the platform who actually has primary responsibility for, and knowledge of, managing your portfolio. They’re mainly there to answer questions about the system.

You want at least some measure of control over your investments. One of the limitations of robo advisors is that they’re pretty much hands-off activities. The platform will have you complete a brief questionnaire that will determine your risk tolerance, then a portfolio will be designed based on that tolerance. You will not have an opportunity to customize your portfolio in any way. You won’t be able to load up your portfolio with Apple stock as part of the allocation. In fact, most robo advisors don’t hold any individual stocks at all.

You don’t agree with the investment allocation robo advisors use. Beyond the lack of control over your investments discussed above, a robo advisor arrangement may not work for you if you’re not comfortable with the actual allocation that’s assigned to your portfolio. Because they are fully automated, robo advisors simply don’t have the kind of investment flexibility you can get with a traditional investment advisor.

Most of your money is in an employer-sponsored retirement plan. Because employer-sponsored retirement plans like 401(k)s are directly managed by an investment trustee, you cannot put the assets under the control of the robo advisor. The most you can get will be investment allocation recommendations from the platform that you may or may not be able to extend to your 401(k). If most or all of your investment funds are in your retirement plan, a robo advisor will be little use to you.

Summary

Robo advisors can work very well in a lot of situations. But since everyone’s situation and temperaments are different, you still need to weigh the options of whether a traditional investment advisor will work better for you and your investing style.

Readers: Which do you prefer? Do you use a robo advisor or traditional advisor for your investments?

Share25
Tweet18
Share42
Reddit
Email

Author: Kevin Mercadante
Updated: February 7, 2018
Category: Robo Advisors
Tags: financial advisor, robo advisor

Choosing the Right Robo Advisor

With so many automated investment services do you fear you'll pick the wrong one? Get expert advice from our FREE ten-day boot camp.
Join our Robo-Advisor Boot Camp

Suggested For You

  • Robo Advisors

    The Rise of the Robo Advisors - Should You Use One?

    Can computers via automated investment services replace financial advisors and give sound investment advice?

  • 5 Ways Robo-Advisors Are Changing the Investment Industry

    Like it or not, robo advisor platforms are a game-changer for the investment industry. Here are the top five ways we've seen that these robo investing services are shaking up the sector.

  • investing technology

    9 Smartphone Apps for Investors - Which is the Best One?

    There are a lot of investment and money management apps available today. So how do you know which one is right for you and your investment situation? After reviewing many different apps, tools, and software programs, we’ve come up with a comparison list for smart investors. […]

Comments

Notify of



Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Buzz M
30 days 8 hours ago

Have a question. If Robo-Advisors don’t invest in stocks,/bonds/etc., what is the basis for gains/losses/equity?

0
 |     Reply   Hide Replies ∧
Joe T
1 year 1 month ago

Also late to the discussion. Robo-Advisors are not just for the newbies or those that have little invested. I’ve made my own financial investment decisions for decades and done very well but now after dipping my big toe into robo-advisors I’m increasing the amount of investments I’m giving to them to control.

At first the robo fees, even though low especially by comparison to a human advisor, bothered me, however I am finding that the robo’s I’ve tried (Future Advisor and Betterment) are doing a good job and beating my own investment decisions by a pretty good margin. So they are worth the fees in my view.

I do think it’s good advice to diversify your robo-advisors just as you would anything else, use more than one on different accounts. Most want you to deposit your money with them but at least one, Future Advisor, will manage existing IRA or Brokerage accounts at Fidelity, meaning you can easily turn it on and off without the hassle of actually moving money.

Great article. thanks.

3
 |     Reply   Hide Replies ∧
Multimillionaireroad
1 year 1 month ago

Sorry I’m late to this discussion. I have to say that I’d suggest that for anyone with a bit of personal finance knowledge you are much better served by organising your own finances rather than paying anyone else, including a robo-advisor. Who/ what else will have your absolute best interest at the forefront?

0
 |     Reply   Hide Replies ∧
Joe T
1 year 1 month ago

Agree that a relationship with a human adviser can be messy and involve possible conflicts of interest. But how could a Robo-Adviser possibly not have your interests at the forefront? Clearly a commissioned human adviser can be influenced by self-interest due to sales quotas, trade commissions, bonus programs and so forth. But a computer algorithm doesn’t care about any of that and since it’s owner is compensated strictly on a fraction of a percent of your total portfolio it’s interests are perfectly aligned with yours!

I have shunned human advisers all my life but the Robo firms have professional data scientists and mathematicians focused full-time on building computer models maximizing the efficiency of your investment allocations. I am skeptical that an individual person can match their level of sophistication. Why not leverage that?

3
 |     Reply   Hide Replies ∧
JeffreyW
1 year 11 months ago

Or use both. And why risk all your money with one robo-advisor. None of them have a very long track record.

4
 |     Reply   Hide Replies ∧
Jorgan
2 years 11 months ago

Nice summary, good advice. But nobody–not you, not the WSJ or any other business pub or site– is doing a quant comparison. Easily done in order to compare returns across advisers. Yes, there is grunt work, but someone needs to do it. Most people invest to make money in line with their risk tolerance. Show them the money

0
 |     Reply   Hide Replies ∧
Mark Zoril
2 years 11 months ago

As an adviser to the middle class, I believe that consumers should use robo advisers whenever they can for investment management. They are significantly less expensive and introduce strong discipline into the process. IMHO, the adviser can provide guidance on planning issues – big picture – and helping control behavioral issues for investors. I believe that adviser compensation should not be tied to assets under management at all but should be based upon the amount of time the client requires. Many advisers currently sell their value as managing assets and charge as such and I do not believe that serves the investor well, even if the adviser is a fiduciary.

Asset allocation is headed towards commodity status, but people will still planning guidance in the future.

10
 |     Reply   Hide Replies ∧
wpDiscuz

Advertiser Disclosure

Investor Junkie has advertising relationships with some of the offers listed on this website. Investor Junkie does attempt to take a reasonable and good faith approach to maintaining objectivity towards providing referrals that are in the best interest of readers. Investor Junkie strives to keep its information accurate and up to date. The information on Investor Junkie could be different from what you find when visiting a third-party website. All products are presented without warranty. For more information, please read our full disclaimer.

Featured Robo Advisor Reviews

  • Betterment (recommended)
  • Blooom (recommended)
  • Ellevest
  • M1 Finance
  • Schwab
  • SoFi Wealth Management
  • Personal Capital
  • Vanguard
  • Wealthfront (recommended)
  • Wealthsimple

Compare

  • Betterment vs. Wealthfront
  • Wealthfront vs. Wealthsimple
  • Schwab vs. Betterment
  • Charles Schwab vs. Wealthfront
  • Betterment vs. Vanguard
  • Compare Other Robo Advisors

Robo Advisor Resources

  • Robo Advisor Overview
  • Free Robo Advisor Bootcamp
  • The Best Robo Advisors
  • True Costs of the Robo Advisors
  • How Robo Advisors are Changing Investing
  • What is Tax Loss Harvesting?
  • What is Smart Beta?
  • What is Socially Responsible Investing?

Recent Robo Advisor Articles

Betterment vs. Vanguard – Which Robo Advisor Is Better? How Wealthfront Is Trying to Beat Indexing 5 Ways Robo-Advisors Are Changing the Investment Industry 5 Ways Robo Advisors Reduce the Cost of Investing Can Retirees Use Robo Advisors Too?

Robo Advisor Promotions

  • Acorns
  • Betterment
  • Blooom
  • Ellevest
  • Qapital
  • Stash Invest
  • Wealthfront
  • Wealthsimple

Investor Junkie

Helping make finance easy. Investor Junkie is your shortcut to financial freedom. We know that managing finances is not easy. We analyze and compare tools to help you make the best decisions for your personal financial situation.

© 2018 Empowering Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved
Subscribe to the Investor Junkie Newsletter
  • About
  • Careers
  • Contact
  • Advertise
  • Privacy
  • Disclaimer

Stay Connected to Investor Junkie

  • subscribe unsubscribe

Investor Junkie is a financial publisher that does not offer any personal financial advice or advocate the purchase or sale of any security or investment for any specific individual. Members should be aware that investment markets have inherent risks, and past performance does not assure future results. Investor Junkie has advertising relationships with some of the offers listed on this website. Investor Junkie does attempt to take a reasonable and good faith approach to maintaining objectivity towards providing referrals that are in the best interest of readers. Investor Junkie strives to keep its information accurate and up to date. The information on Investor Junkie could be different from what you find when visiting a third-party website. All products are presented without warranty. For more information, please read our full disclaimer.